ShowHide the Study Notes (2,065 words)
CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: nine verses. Kept, with the Arabic unchanged: 2:186, 72:2, 2:256, 11:97, 11:87, 18:66, 11:78 and 49:7. Appended, new to the book: 18:17 from man yahdi llāhu, the one murshid in the Qurʼan, denied to the one Allah leaves astray. Duʻāʼ: Qurʼan 18:10, the one supplication among the root’s nineteen occurrences, in Name 77’s Arabic and English and linked with it as an exact share; and Abū Dāwūd 1425 with at-Tirmidhī 464, the opening of the qunūt, kept, with the source and grade Names 25 and 46 give. Ḥadīth: Abū Dāwūd 4607, now alone in its source; and al-Bukhārī 6382, the istikhārah, kept.
NAMED HERE BUT NOT CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: 7:146, carried at Name 10; 4:6, carried at Name 40; 72:14, carried at Name 86; 21:51, 40:29, 40:38, 18:24, 72:10, 72:21, 18:10, 72:1, 18:65, 18:67, 18:78 and 49:8, all carried at NO Name.
CORRECTED ON THE RECORD, THE COUNT: the entry had none. R-sh-d counted on the pointed Tanzil text with the pause marks removed (count_rshd.py, every word given one sense and asserted in build_N98.py). Rāʼ, shīn and dāl in order with at most one letter between return 19 words in 19 verses; up to three letters between, and at any distance, return none more, and no word of another root is returned. Of people 8: yarshudūn 2:186, the orphans 4:6, rajulun rashīd 11:78, Shuʻayb 11:87, Mūsā asking 18:66, Ibrāhīm 21:51, ar-rāshidūn 49:7, the jinn who submitted 72:14. A way 3: 7:146, set against sabīl al-ghayy, and sabīl ar-rashād at 40:29 and 40:38. From Allah or in His power alone 3: 18:24, 72:10, set against sharr, and 72:21, set against ḍarr. The right course 2: 2:256, set against al-ghayy, and 72:2. A command 1, Pharaoh’s, denied it: 11:97. A guide 1, denied: 18:17. A supplication 1: 18:10. Tested on the count and true: the ref’s nineteen; rashīd only at 11:78, 11:87 and 11:97, all in Sūrat Hūd; ar-rashīd once, at 11:87, said of Shuʻayb by his people; ar-rāshidūn the only rāshid and the root’s only plural participle. None of the nineteen is said of Allah, and rashīd is never said of His command. At 40:29 sabīl ar-rashād is Pharaoh’s word, after the believer of his family has spoken (40:28); at 40:38 it is the believer’s.
CORRECTED ON THE RECORD, THE PAGE: FOUND FALSE AND CORRECTED — the desc, the meditation and the root gloss gave rushd as soundness of judgment; Ibn Fāris gives the root as the straightness of the way and rushd as the opposite of ghayy, and all three now follow him. The meditation called Pharaoh the most powerful man in the ancient world, running the largest administration on earth; no source read says so, and the sentence now gives the verse. Name 32’s note on 11:87 said aṭ-Ṭabarī takes the words at face value; aṭ-Ṭabarī glosses al-ḥalīm and ar-rashīd and then says they said it to him in mockery, and Name 32’s note now says so. The ḥadīth note said the tail min baʻdī after the caliphs belongs to other routes; none of the four records in the six editions that name the caliphs, Abū Dāwūd 4607, at-Tirmidhī 2676 and Ibn Mājah 42 and 43, has it there, and no other route was read. The source Abū Dāwūd 4607; at-Tirmidhī 2676 paired two records where at-Tirmidhī 2676 does not carry the printed words; it stands in the note with its rows. The meditation said Mūsā watches the servant scuttle a working boat; at 18:71 the boat is holed, and the word now says so. The meditation quoted 2:256, 18:66 and al-Bukhārī 6382 in words other than the page’s; it now quotes the page, with the numbers. The poem opened on an orchestra that tunes once, before the doors of the hall are opened, with the audience arriving after; the practice described in a violinist.com forum thread, search results only, no page opened, is tuning on stage at the start and again in the second half, and the poem now tunes to one note before the first bar is played, with the seats already full. REMOVED AS UNVERIFIED — the desc’s no counselor to consult and no revision to make, and its most powerful administration of the ancient world; the 2:186 note’s comparison with Names 71 and 72, which was not counted; the 72:2 note’s claim that the Name is inferred from this pattern of usage; the 11:97 note’s worst ruler named in the Qurʼan; the earlier Study Note’s claim that 4:6 is carried at Name 40, which carries only its end. SOURCED — the reading of 11:87 as mockery, now given as aṭ-Ṭabarī’s, who says the people of interpretation said so, Ibn Kathīr’s, with his five names, and as-Saʻdī’s, with al-Qurṭubī’s preference for the earnest reading; the title conferred rather than attained at 49:7, now Ibn Kathīr’s, those to whom Allah gave their rushd, and as-Saʻdī’s, not by their own power. The English of 2:256 and 18:66 carries no brackets and that of 11:87 and 18:66 no quotation marks, in the book’s own style; 11:87 reads the same at Name 32, and 2:186 closes that they may be rightly guided here and at Name 44.
THE SIX EDITIONS: ar-rashīd in two records, both at-Tirmidhī, both read: 3507, the list, al-wārith ar-rashīd aṣ-ṣabūr: gharīb (at-Tirmidhī’s own verdict); ḍaʻīf (Aḥmad Shākir; al-Albānī; Darussalam); and 3419, allāhumma dhā l-ḥabli sh-shadīdi wa-l-amri r-rashīd, in a long supplication from Ibn ʻAbbās that also asks tulhimunī bihā rushdī: gharīb (at-Tirmidhī’s own verdict); ḍaʻīf al-isnād (Aḥmad Shākir; al-Albānī); ḍaʻīf (Bashshār ʻAwwād Maʻrūf; Darussalam). The list at Ibn Mājah 3861 has ar-rāshid. The root swept in all six with the narrator Rushdayn and the bare name Rāshid set aside: 87 words, read in their places, among them the narrator Dāwūd ibn Rushayd many times. Supplications with the root: at-Tirmidhī 3483, allāhumma alhimnī rushdī wa-aʻidhnī min sharri nafsī: ḥasan gharīb (at-Tirmidhī’s own verdict); ḥasan (Bashshār ʻAwwād Maʻrūf); ḍaʻīf (Aḥmad Shākir; al-Albānī; Darussalam); at-Tirmidhī 3407 and an-Nasāʼī 1304, the resolve upon rushd, ḍaʻīf by their rows except Darussalam’s ḥasan at an-Nasāʼī 1304; Abū Dāwūd 517 and at-Tirmidhī 207, allāhumma arshid al-aʼimmah, for the imams: ṣaḥīḥ (al-Albānī), ḥasan (Darussalam) at Abū Dāwūd 517; ṣaḥīḥ (Aḥmad Shākir; al-Albānī), ḥasan (Darussalam) at at-Tirmidhī 207. No supplication calls on Allah as ar-Rashīd. The rightly guided caliphs stand at Abū Dāwūd 4607, at-Tirmidhī 2676 and Ibn Mājah 42 and 43 only. The istikhārah’s close reads thumma raḍḍinī bihi at al-Bukhārī 6382 and 7390, Abū Dāwūd 1538 and Ibn Mājah 1383, and thumma arḍinī bihi at al-Bukhārī 1166, at-Tirmidhī 480 and an-Nasāʼī 3253. The wording Ibn Kathīr gives at 18:10 as in the ḥadīth, fa-jʻal ʻāqibatahu rashadā, was not found in the six by this sweep.
READ: Ibn Fāris, Maqāyīs al-Lughah (Shamela book 21710), r-sh-d at vol. 2, p. 398, the whole entry. Aṭ-Ṭabarī at 2:186 on laʻallahum yarshudūn, 2:256 on ar-rushd and al-ghayy, 11:78 on rajulun rashīd, 11:87, 11:96–97, 18:10, 18:17, 18:66–67, 21:51–52, 40:29, 40:38, 49:7–8 and 72:1–2. Ibn Kathīr at 2:256 on its occasion, 11:78, 11:87, 11:97, 18:10, 18:17, 18:66, 21:51, 40:29, 40:38, 49:7 and 72:2. As-Saʻdī at 2:256, 11:87 and 49:7–8. Al-Qurṭubī at 11:87. Letter by letter with their grade rows: Abū Dāwūd 1425 and 4607; at-Tirmidhī 464, 2676, 3419, 3483 and 3507; Ibn Mājah 42, 43 and 3861; al-Bukhārī 1166, 6382 and 7390, and the istikhārah’s close at Abū Dāwūd 1538, at-Tirmidhī 480, an-Nasāʼī 3253 and Ibn Mājah 1383. The young trees of the story: Wisconsin Fruit, Michigan State University Extension, Wafler Nursery, the RHS and Iowa State University Extension on removing blossom from young apple trees and on alternate bearing, search results only, no page opened. The drift of the poem’s instruments: Mini Physics and an Acoustical Society of America lay paper on strings going flat and winds going sharp as they warm, search results only, no page opened.
NOT READ: al-Mujmal, al-Jawharī, al-Khalīl’s al-ʻAyn, ar-Rāghib and Lisān al-ʻArab for r-sh-d in print; al-Baghawī and Ibn ʻĀshūr at every verse of this page, and al-Qurṭubī except at 11:87, downloaded; as-Saʻdī at 2:186, 11:78, 11:97, 18:10, 18:17, 18:66, 21:51, 40:29, 40:38 and 72:2; Ibn Kathīr at 2:186, where the file read does not carry the phrase; any commentary at 4:6, 7:146, 18:24, 72:10, 72:14 and 72:21; the 148 words spelled Rāshid, names, beyond the count.
OPEN: whether occurrence should read derived when the page now carries 18:17, where guidance and its denial are Allah’s but the root is said of a guide denied; left derived, for the author. The poem’s No player can hear it happening to himself and its after three hours are hyperbole; kept. The story’s rule of three years without fruit sits at the long end of the nursery advice seen, which runs from one year to three; kept as the old orchardist’s. The story’s fifty-seven years on and about forty years are its own figures; kept. The meditation’s His direction of the whole affair requires no advisor, admits no revision is the meditation’s own reflection and is not given to a source; kept. At Name 91 the English of 21:69 still carries quotation marks, for that Name’s audit.
COHERENCE: Name 10 carries the opening of 7:146 and not its sabīl ar-rushd, and Name 40 the end of 4:6 and not the rushd of the orphans. The desc, the ref and the notes give the same nineteen words, the same three places of rashīd, the same Ibn Fāris and the same readings of 11:87 under the same numbers; 11:87 is carried at Name 32 in the same Arabic and English, and Name 32’s note and Study Note record aṭ-Ṭabarī’s own words; 18:10 is linked with Name 77 as an exact share, and Name 77’s Study Note records it; the close of 2:186 reads the same at Name 44, whose Study Note records it; the meditation quotes 2:256, 18:66, 11:97 and al-Bukhārī 6382 in the book’s English, and its close, that Mūsā was not shown the reason until the third objection, agrees with 18:77–78. AFTER THE CHAT-END AUDIT OF 81–85: the grade field of Abū Dāwūd 4607; at-Tirmidhī 2676 now gives every grader in the dataset’s rows, each attributed to its record (the grade survey). AFTER THE CHAT-END AUDIT OF 1–99: the link to Name 71 was read on both pages and stands.
ON THE AUTHOR’S DECISION, THE STATUS LINE: the author keeps derived from root / enumeration. The question was whether carrying 18:17 raises it; it does not. The count on this page is that rashīd stands three times and ar-rashīd once, at 11:87, and that none of the four is said of Allah; 18:17 carries guidance and its denial as Allah’s in the verb, not in the Name-form. The value the page has is the one the count supports. The item is closed.
ON THE AUTHOR’S LIST, THE RECORDED GROUP: the list gathers in one place the passages of the creative pages that are the author’s own and are kept, so that no later pass corrects them. The entries at this Name are the two hyperboles of POEMS 98, the rule of three years without fruit in CH 98 with the years that story counts, and the meditation’s own sentence that His direction of the whole affair requires no advisor and admits no revision. This note already records them; that record stands, the passages are unchanged, and they stay with him.
IN BUILD 196, FROM THE BACKLOG READING OF THE LEXICA: ar-Rāghib (al-Mufradāt, p. 354), Lisān al-ʻArab (in IslamWeb’s transcription) and al-Khalīl (al-ʻAyn, vol. 6, p. 242) are read through the web page reader, not in print, for r-sh-d: rashad and rushd are the opposite of ghayy and are used as guidance is used; Lisān gives ar-rashīd as the One who directs creation to what is good for them, faʻīl in the sense of mufʻil; al-Khalīl, rushd the opposite of ghayy; nothing on this page is at odds with them; al-Jawharī and al-Mujmal are still not reached.
IN BUILD 206, FROM THE BACKLOG READING OF THE LEXICA: al-Jawharī and Ibn Fāris’s al-Mujmal are read at Shamela through its page reader, not in print: aṣ-Ṣiḥāḥ, vol. 2, p. 474, gives ar-rashād as the opposite of al-ghayy and al-marāshid as the aims of roads; al-Mujmal, p. 379, gives ar-rushd as the opposite of al-ghayy and al-marāshid likewise; nothing on this page is at odds with them, and the NOT READ line owes the five lexica in print only.