ShowHide the Study Notes (1,749 words)
CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: EIGHT ayat. Carried before: 11:61, 2:186 and 40:60.
ADDED: 37:75, 21:88, 13:14, 29:24 and 89:9. All five are appended, the three existing sub-items keep their positions, none of the five is carried at any other Name so no reciprocal links were needed, and the distinct verse count in Notes on This Edition moves from 411 to 416. 2:186 IS EXTENDED rather than added to: the printed portion now runs to the end of the verse.
NAMED HERE BUT NOT CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: 35:14, carried at Name 31; 34:13, carried at Name 35; 7:82, 27:56, 29:29, 42:47, 7:194, 11:14, 18:52, 28:50, 28:64, 46:5, 5:109, 28:65, 21:87, 21:76 and 21:90, all carried at NO Name; 21:84, carried at Name 91; 8:24, carried at Name 60.
CORRECTED ON THE RECORD, THE COUNT, AND THE ENTRY HAD NONE: counted by hand from the Tanzil text with strip, j-w-b gives FORTY-FOUR words. THE METHOD TRAP HERE IS THE HOLLOW ROOT, and it is the third of its kind in this stretch after the geminate at j-l-l and the sister-entry problem at k-r-m: the wāw is absent from ajāba, yujīb, istajāba, mujīb and jawāb alike, so a j then w then b regex finds almost nothing. The sweep must be run as jīm then bāʼ, which returns 189 words in 103 forms, and every one was read by hand — j-b-l alone accounts for forty-one (corrected in build 168), and j-b-r, j-b-y, j-n-b, j-y-b, j-b-b, ʻ-j-b, ḥ-j-b and w-j-b take most of the rest, with j-b-t, j-b-h, j-l-b, j-b-n, Jibrīl and zanjabīl (named in build 168).
THE FIRST FINDING, AND THE ENTRY HAD ASSERTED THE OPPOSITE: the ref said the Qurʼan gives mujīb in the indefinite and that the definite al-Mujīb comes only from the enumeration. THE DEFINITE FORM IS IN THE BOOK. Al-mujībūn, the majestic plural, stands at 37:75 and is of Allah — wa-laqad nādānā Nūḥun fa-la-niʻma l-mujībūn. Aṭ-Ṭabarī glosses it as how excellent the Responders We were to him when he called Us: We answered his call AND DESTROYED HIS PEOPLE, the call in question being Nūḥ asking that no dweller of the deniers be left on the earth. So the single definite occurrence of this Name-form names a flood as the answer, which is worth having on a page about answered prayer.
THE SECOND FINDING: the noun jawāb occurs FOUR times and every one is a rejecting people answering a prophet — drive them out at 7:82 and 27:56, kill him or burn him at 29:24, and 29:29. The only noun of answering in the Qurʼan is always the wrong answer and it is always in human mouths. 29:24 is carried for it.
THE THIRD FINDING: the verb runs in both directions and toward Allah more often than from Him. Istajībū is an imperative to human beings at 8:24 and 42:47; alladhīna stajābū li-llāhi wa-r-rasūl at 3:172 and alladhīna istajābū li-rabbihim at 13:18 and 42:38 (corrected in build 168); ajībū dāʻiya llāh at 46:31 and man lā yujib at 46:32; and 2:186 HOLDS BOTH DIRECTIONS IN ONE SENTENCE, ujību and then fa-l-yastajībū lī — which is exactly the half the page had been cutting off, so the portion is extended. Seven further places negate the verb of what is called besides Allah (corrected in build 168: at 28:50 it is the deniers not answering the Prophet ﷺ, in aṭ-Ṭabarī’s reading), and at 5:109 and 28:65 the question is turned round at the Reckoning: what answer were you given, what did you answer the messengers. 13:14 is carried for the negative set.
CORRECTED, THE ROOT FIELDS: glossBasis was desc and senseNote was null. IBN FĀRIS WAS READ IN HIS OWN TEXT, in Maqāyīs al-Lugha at the chapter of jīm and wāw, and HE DOES NOT MAKE THIS ONE ROOT BUT TWO. The first is kharq ash-shayʼ, the piercing of a thing — jubtu l-arḍa jawban, I cut across the land; jāʼibatu khabar, news that cuts across the countries; al-jawbah, a hollow, which he says is of this chapter because it is like a piercing in the ground. The second, given in three words, is murājaʻat al-kalām, THE RETURNING OF SPEECH, and that is the Name’s root: an answer is words coming back. He adds the proverb asāʼa samʻan fa-asāʼa jābah, he heard badly so he answered badly. THE QURʼAN USES BOTH ROOTS AND USES THE FIRST OF THAMŪD: 89:9, alladhīna jābū ṣ-ṣakhra bi-l-wād, and 34:13, jifānin ka-l-jawāb. Thamūd are also the people addressed at 11:61, where Ṣāliḥ tells them his Lord is qarībun mujīb. 89:9 is carried so that the page holds the whole root and not the half of it that suits the Name.
NOT READ: no other lexicon was reached for j-w-b; the aggregator was not tried for this root and nothing is claimed from one. FOUND IN TAFSĪR: as-Saʻdī on 11:61 divides the responding into the prayer of request and the prayer of worship, answering the one by giving what was asked and the other BY ACCEPTING IT — so ijābah is not only the granting of petitions, which the entry had assumed throughout. CORRECTED, THE ḤADĪTH, AND BOTH ITEMS WERE ON THE BACKLOG: Musnad Aḥmad 11133 HAD A SOURCE FIELD OF NINETY-FOUR CHARACTERS holding a narrator, a parallel work and a remark, Arabic punctuation in its ar, and the phrase the Reflection in its note, which notes may not carry. All three are cleared; the punctuation is stripped with the letters asserted unchanged. At-Tirmidhī 3505 said the grade row on the cited page is Darussalam’s.
THERE ARE THREE ROWS: Aḥmad Shākir and al-Albānī ṣaḥīḥ, and Darussalam ISNĀD ṣaḥīḥ, which is a verdict on the chain.
CORRECTED, A MISATTRIBUTED CLAUSE: the ref gave Muslim 2735a for the servant being answered so long as he does not ask for sin or the severing of kinship. 2735a AND 2735b CARRY ONLY THE HASTE CONDITION, yustajābu li-aḥadikum mā lam yaʻjal; the sin and kinship clause is 2735c’s. 2735c is now added as a third report and both numbers are given where each belongs. Its own gloss of haste is the best thing on the page: asked what haste is, the Prophet ﷺ said the man says I have called and called and I have not seen Him answer me, and at that he grows weary and gives up supplicating.
CORRECTED, THE HOUSE FORMS: the ref carried Jāmiʻ at-Tirmidhī 3507 and Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2735a; both are now house forms. MEDS 44, POEMS 44 and CH 44 read and left unchanged.
OPEN: 21:76 and 21:90, two of the other three of the four fa-stajabnā lahu in one passage, are carried at NO Name, and so are 3:195, 8:9, 12:34, 10:89 and 42:26, every one of them a place where the answering is predicated of Allah. A later pass could take the set.
OPEN: 34:13, the basins like cisterns, is carried at Name 35 for a different word and is the root’s second use in the piercing sense if al-jawāb is the hollow, al-jawbah, as Ibn Kathīr reports Ibn ʻAbbās and al-Qurṭubī Mujāhid; aṭ-Ṭabarī and Ibn Kathīr derive it from al-jābiyah, and without it the root has forty-three (build 168); it is named here and not moved.
OPEN: 14:22, where it is SATAN who says fa-stajabtum lī, you responded to me, is the sharpest use of the verb in the Book and is carried nowhere.
COHERENCE: Name 20 keeps Qurʼan 21:87 unchanged and this Name keeps it too, now with 21:88 beside it. EXTENDING 2:186 CHANGED TWO SHARED_LOCI KINDS: Name 36 prints the first half of that verse and NAME 98 PRINTS EXACTLY THE SECOND HALF, the clause added here, so the link between 44 and 36 moves from equal extent to different extent and Name 36's own row is moved with it; the link to 98 was already different extent and stands. Name 21's Study Note listed 13:14 among verses carried at NO Name and that claim was made stale by this append; it is corrected. Nothing else outside this Name was touched.
HYGIENE AFTER NAME 61: the Qurʼan note on 2:186 narrated the page’s own editing — The printed portion is extended to the end of the verse because the second half is the point the page had been cutting off — and the clause is removed with the fact it carried kept; the Qurʼan note on 37:75 narrated the page’s own editing — said of Allah, and the entry had stated that the Qurʼan gives mujīb only in the indefinite — and the clause is removed with the fact it carried kept; the Qurʼan note on 21:88 narrated the page’s own editing — this is the next verse, and the page had the asking without the answering — and the clause is removed with the fact it carried kept.
AFTER NAME 91: 21:84 is now carried at Name 91, and the NAMED line and the open item say so.
AFTER NAME 98: 2:186 closes that they may be rightly guided, the same words Name 98 prints for the verse’s close. AFTER THE CHAT-END AUDIT OF 1–99: the capitalised runs in the desc and the ref are set in lower case, the words unchanged.
IN BUILD 168, FROM THE PHASE 2 READING: the ref names j-b-t, j-b-h, j-l-b and j-b-n with Jibrīl and zanjabīl among the look-alikes, counts seven places that negate the answering of what is called besides Allah and gives 28:50 as the deniers not answering the Prophet ﷺ, runs the verb as often toward Allah as from Him, names Ibn Mājah 3861’s list beside at-Tirmidhī 3507, reads his own text, and no longer narrates its editing; the desc gives the definite form in the plural; the senseNote, the 89:9 note and the OPEN item give both derivations of al-jawāb at 34:13; the 2:186 note drops the most cited verse and turns its comparison to the counts; the 40:60 note gives astajib as ajāba’s meaning in aṭ-Ṭabarī; the 13:14 note counts seven; the duʻāʼ and ḥadīth notes no longer narrate their editing, the note on Musnad Aḥmad 11133 names at-Tirmidhī 3573 from ʻUbādah ibn aṣ-Ṣāmit, and the note on Muslim 2735c gives the routes of the three tellings. The Study Note’s j-b-l, look-alikes, seven places and 3:172 are corrected in place. Musnad Aḥmad 11133 and the print lexica stay outside the kit.
BY THE AUTHOR’S DECISIONS OF 2026-09-25, IN BUILD 182: 2:186 takes Name 36’s English for the words both pages print and keeps its own close, which Name 98 gives word for word (A48, A23).