ShowHide the Study Notes (1,072 words)
CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: EIGHT ayat. 59:24, al-Khāliqu l-Bāriʼu l-Muṣawwir, the one definite occurrence of the Name, SHARED WITH NAMES 12 AND 13, its note now giving al-Qurṭubī, al-Baghawī and Ibn Kathīr for the reading of the triad as measuring, bringing-forth and form, and Ibn ʻĀshūr for the wider reading; 6:102, khāliqu kulli shayʼin, SHARED WITH NAME 52, with aṭ-Ṭabarī; 15:86, the intensive al-Khallāq, with Ibn Kathīr and aṭ-Ṭabarī; 25:2, khalaqa kulla shayʼin fa-qaddarahu taqdīran, with aṭ-Ṭabarī, al-Baghawī and al-Qurṭubī; 36:81, the intensive again, with aṭ-Ṭabarī and Ibn Kathīr; 40:62, khāliqu kulli shayʼin in the other order, with aṭ-Ṭabarī; and, ADDED, 16:17, is He who creates like one who does not create, with Qatādah in aṭ-Ṭabarī and Ibn ʻĀshūr, carried at this Name only; and, ADDED, 52:35–36, am humu l-khāliqūn, with Ibn Kathīr, aṭ-Ṭabarī and al-Bukhārī 4854, carried at this Name only. Both are appended, so sub-items 0 to 5 keep their positions and SHARED_LOCI needs no remap. The distinct Qurʼan-page verse count in Notes on This Edition moves from 338 to 340.
NAMED HERE BUT NOT CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: 13:16, carried at Name 66; 35:3, carried at Name 17; 15:28, 38:71, 39:62, 23:14, 37:125 and 56:59, all carried at NO Name; 16:20, carried at Name 62; 36:78, carried at Name 60; ADDED AT THE CHAT-END AUDIT OF 71–75, the entry names these verses, which this note did not list: 3:191, carried at NO Name;
CORRECTED ON THE RECORD, THE COUNTS: computed from the Tanzil text, the participle khāliq stands eight times in the singular and four in the plural, three plurals of Allah and one, 52:35, of the deniers; khāliqu kulli shayʼ four times; the intensive al-Khallāq twice, at 15:86 and 36:81 (khalāq, portion, at 2:102, 2:200, 3:77 and three times at 9:69, is a different word; 9:69 added in build 147). The earlier record here gave the same figures from the word-by-word corpus, and the Tanzil count confirms them; the process remarks around them are removed.
CORRECTED ON THE RECORD, THE REF: it said al-Ghazālī reads the decree here because of Ibn Fāris’s first root; no such link is made by either, and it is removed. Ibn Fāris gives the example of leather measured for a waterskin, and the cutting is in the verse he and al-Qurṭubī cite, which al-Qurṭubī names as Zuhayr’s. Al-Ghazālī’s wording was read as quoted by Ibn ʻĀshūr on 59:24, not in an edition of al-Maqṣad al-Asnā; Ibn al-ʻArabī’s ʻĀriḍat al-Aḥwadhī and az-Zamakhsharī were likewise read only through Ibn ʻĀshūr.
CORRECTED, THE DESC: it presented the reading of al-Khāliq as the decree as the commentators’ reading without qualification; Ibn ʻĀshūr takes the wider sense and doubts al-Ghazālī’s scheme, so the division is now stated, unnamed. Its claim that the three acts have no interval between them had no source and is removed.
ROOT: the gloss follows Ibn Fāris with glossBasis ref, and a senseNote is added.
CORRECTED, THE QURʼAN NOTES: the 36:81 and 40:62 notes carried capitals and process remarks, now replaced by attributed notes; 25:2’s note claimed the verse lies behind the commentators’ reading and that the fa- makes the measuring part of the creating, neither sourced, and now gives the commentators’ own glosses; 36:81 now renders al-Khallāq the Supreme Creator, as 15:86 does. TWO duʻāʼ. al-Bukhārī 6306, sayyid al-istighfār, from Shaddād ibn Aws, carried at this Name only.
CORRECTED: it had no grade, and a Prophetic duʻāʼ must carry one; its note no longer calls khalaqtanī a fact of ownership, and gives the report’s closing promise as al-Bukhārī has it.
ADDED: Qurʼan 3:191, rabbanā mā khalaqta hādhā bāṭilan, the verb of the Name, with aṭ-Ṭabarī and Ibn Kathīr, carried at no Name. ONE tracked ḥadīth, carried at this Name alone: the ḥadīth qudsī from Abū Hurayrah.
CORRECTED: its Arabic had a colon, now removed; its source now reads Muslim 2111a, whose wording is quoted, with al-Bukhārī 7559, which has the three items, and the note gives 5953’s shorter wording, 2111b’s omission, al-Bukhārī’s chapter under 37:96, and Ibn Ḥajar’s explanation of the challenge and of dharrah as small ant or mote (superseded: see the record IN BUILD 147 below). The Muslim dataset lacks 2110 to 2112; Muslim’s wording was read on Wikisource and in quotations, and Ibn Ḥajar through the islamweb transcription of Fatḥ al-Bārī.
MEDS 11: it said Allah does not assemble, when 82:8 uses rakkabaka of Him; it now says He does not merely assemble. Its account of 36:81 had the like of them as the heavens and the earth and said He did not have to look anything up; it now follows the verse’s occasion and reads the pairing with knowledge as Ibn Kathīr reads 15:86.
POEMS 11: the deaf composer’s music no longer waits years for an orchestra to exist, and the likeness to the decree is marked as a likeness.
CH 11: the frost now kills the garden back to the ground, which its regrowth in April requires.
OPEN: the composer image recurs at Name 72’s poem; to be weighed there.
AUDIT AFTER NAME 65: the Qurʼan link for 6:102 to Name 52 was of the kind the reader shows as Also at, which says the same text is printed there, and that page prints different Arabic; it is now shown as Another portion at. AFTER THE CHAT-END AUDIT OF 1–99: the item asking that the composer image be weighed at Name 72 is closed: Name 72’s poem opens on the composer who writes a rest before the resolution.
IN BUILD 147, FROM THE PHASE 2 READING: the report note no longer tells the story of its own correction, and this record keeps it: an earlier form of the page printed yakhluqu khalqan ka-khalqī and a second li-yakhluqū and gave the wording to Muslim 2111a; neither word is in al-Bukhārī 7559, the edition the book verifies against has no Muslim 2110 to 2112, and ka-khalqī stands in it only at al-Bukhārī 5953 and 7559, so the page prints 7559 letter for letter, leaves Muslim’s wording out and grades it ṣaḥīḥ, al-Bukhārī publishing no rows; the report line above described that earlier form. The note now gives the occasion as al-Bukhārī 5953 has it, a man making images at the top of a house in Madinah, where it had given 7559, which has none, the seeing of images; the ref cites al-Bukhārī 7559 without Muslim 2111a; the counts line gives khalāq at 9:69 as well, six words in four verses.