ShowHide the Study Notes (1,566 words)
CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: SEVEN ayat. 58:1, with aṭ-Ṭabarī on the woman and her husband and Ibn Kathīr on ʻĀʼishah and on ʻUmar; 42:11, SHARED WITH NAME 27, with aṭ-Ṭabarī, al-Qurṭubī and al-Baghawī on the two parsings, al-Wāsiṭī as al-Qurṭubī quotes him, as-Saʻdī on the verse answering two errors at once, and Ibn ʻĀshūr on organs and senses; 14:39, SHARED WITH NAME 16, where aṭ-Ṭabarī reads hearing and Ibn Kathīr answering; 20:46, SHARED WITH NAME 27, with aṭ-Ṭabarī, Ibn Kathīr and al-Qurṭubī; 43:80, with aṭ-Ṭabarī, Ibn Kathīr and Mujāhid.
ADDED: 34:50, the single verse joining the Name to qarīb, which Ibn Kathīr glosses with the very report this page carries, in an-Nasāʼī wording; and 11:24, the one place the definite form is said of a human being, SHARED WITH NAME 27, with aṭ-Ṭabarī, Ibn Kathīr and al-Qurṭubī. Both are appended, the other sub-items keep their positions, and the distinct Qurʼan-page verse count in Notes on This Edition moves from 361 to 363.
NAMED HERE BUT NOT CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: 5:42, carried at Name 86; 76:2, 3:38, 5:41, 9:47, 2:137 and 2:127, all carried at NO Name.
CORRECTED ON THE RECORD, THE COUNTS: computed from the Tanzil text with strip, s-m-ʻ gives 185 words, leaving aside the 12 occurrences of the proper name Ismāʻīl, and look-alikes from m-t-ʻ were excluded. The adjective samīʻ stands 47 times, 20 definite and 27 indefinite; 45 of those are of Allah, 19 definite and 26 indefinite, and 2 are of a human being, the definite form at 11:24 and the indefinite at 76:2. Of the 45, NONE STANDS ALONE: 32 join al-ʻAlīm, 10 join al-Baṣīr, 2 are samīʻu d-duʻāʼ and 1 joins qarīb. The noun samʻ stands 22 times (corrected in build 153) and the intensive sammāʻūn 4, never of Allah.
CORRECTED, THE ROOT: the gloss followed nothing and now follows Ibn Fāris, with glossBasis ref, and a senseNote is added giving the form and the senses of the root that are not the Name’s.
READ: Ibn Fāris on the islamweb transcription; and on the Hawramani transcription Ibn Manẓūr, al-Jawharī, al-Fayyūmī, ar-Rāghib al-Iṣfahānī, az-Zamakhsharī, Ibn Sīdah, al-Muṭarrizī, al-Jurjānī, az-Zabīdī and Lane, with al-Azharī and Ibn al-Athīr as those entries quote them.
NOT READ: al-Bayhaqī and Ibn al-Qayyim in the original, both taken only as quoted in later works, and al-Ghazālī not at all.
CORRECTED, THE DESC: it asserted that He hears the ant’s footstep, that no complaint escapes Him and that nothing reaches Him in translation, none of which the sources give; it said the Name rarely travels alone, where the count shows it never does; it stated as fact that one room and one woman became a chapter without naming the report that settles it; and it closed on a promise, that He acts upon what He hears for the good of the caller. The new desc gives the root sense, the intensive form, the three readings, the pairings by count, and what the Name asks.
CORRECTED, THE REF: it carried long citation forms, Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 6384 and Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2704a, now in house form; it named no lexicon and no commentator, and gave no counts. It now gives the counts, ten lexicographers, the commentators by name, the three reports, and at-Tirmidhī 3507 with its grades.
CORRECTED, THE QURʼAN NOTES: 58:1 asserted that Allah above the seven heavens heard the woman with no source, which is ʻUmar’s wording in a chain Ibn Kathīr himself calls broken between Abū Yazīd and ʻUmar, and the note now says so; 42:11 said the verse is what the tradition returns to, and now gives four commentators and the reading rule; 14:39 asserted decades of waiting, which aṭ-Ṭabarī gives only through a shaykh he does not name, and the note now rests on the verse’s own ʻalā l-kibar; 20:46 and 43:80 carried no commentator at all. THE TRANSLATION OF 14:39 DIVERGED BETWEEN NAMES 16 AND 26 for the same verse, in my old age against despite old age and the Hearer of prayer against the Hearer of supplication; both now read the Hearer of supplication, and Name 16’s 3:38 is brought to the same rendering of the same construct. THREE duʻāʼ. 2:127 CORRECTED: its note said the prayer was said with no one else present to hear it, which no source gives and which aṭ-Ṭabarī contradicts by recording a division over who the speaker was; the note now gives Ibn ʻAbbās through Saʻīd ibn Jubayr in aṭ-Ṭabarī, that division, and Ibn Kathīr with Wuhayb ibn al-Ward.
ADDED: 3:38, the second and last place samīʻu d-duʻāʼ stands, SHARED WITH NAME 16, where it is read for the imperative hab; and at-Tirmidhī 242, the transmitted supplication that calls on Allah by this Name, SHARED WITH NAME 19, its source and grade strings copied unchanged so that the two pages agree. SHARED_LOCI: reciprocal dua links are added at 16, 19 and 26, and a dua key for 16 is created in numeric order. THREE aḥādīth. al-Bukhārī 6384 with Muslim 2704a, SHARED WITH NAMES 27 AND 53 as other portions (named in build 153), CORRECTED: the note carried a production remark and a capitalised field name, both removed, and it now adds Muslim 2704f, that the One called is nearer than the neck of a mount, and Ibn Kathīr citing the report under 34:50. Ibn Mājah 188 CORRECTED: its source was the long form Sunan Ibn Mājah 188, now in house form; its grade gave Darussalam alone, and the dataset carries four graders, al-Albānī, Muḥammad Fuʼād ʻAbd al-Bāqī, Shuʻayb al-Arnaʼūṭ and Darussalam, all ṣaḥīḥ; its note pointed at another page of the book and is now confined to the report, with Ibn Kathīr on its other routes and on Ibn Abī Ḥātim’s differing wording.
ADDED: al-Bukhārī 796 with Muslim 409a, from Abū Hurayrah, the Name’s own verb said of Allah in the prayer, carried at no other Name, ṣaḥīḥ muttafaq ʻalayh, with Ibn al-Athīr, al-Fayyūmī, Ibn al-Anbārī and az-Zamakhsharī on the sense of the verb there.
MEDS 26: p1 called being heard one of the deepest human needs and a listener a sanctuary, both unsupported, and now says only that people go looking to be heard and that a listener is rare; p2 quoted 58:1 and Ibn Mājah 188 in wordings the book does not use, now brought to the book’s own, and attributes the seven heavens to ʻUmar by name; p3 quoted the report of Abū Mūsā and 43:80 loosely, both now in the book’s own wording, with the Companion named; p4 claimed that everything entering a real listener stays there, replaced by what falls into a listener is a trust.
POEMS 26: stanza 2 said the head turns every time, which the work on selective attention does not support, and now says often enough to be uncanny, and the claim that the thread is never lost is softened to mostly.
CH 26: one phrase reworded.
OPEN: Ibn Kathīr reports that al-Bukhārī carries the ʻĀʼishah report in suspended form in the Book of Tawḥīd, and the printed edition footnotes it to 7385, but that number in the dataset is a different report, the night supplication of Ibn ʻAbbās, and the suspended text is not in the dataset at all; no number is asserted here.
OPEN: aṭ-Ṭabarī transmits, from Ḍirār ibn Murrah who heard it from a shaykh he does not name, that Ibrāhīm received the tidings at a hundred and seventeen; it is not used.
AUDIT: the samīʻ counts were taken by matching the adjective forms exactly and the partner word by position, so a reader checking them should count the word that follows each occurrence.
COHERENCE: Name 16 is edited twice, at 14:39 on its Qurʼan page and at 3:38 on its Duʻāʼ page, for the two renderings above; Name 19 gains a reciprocal shared link only, with no change to its text; Name 53, which carries al-Bukhārī 6384 with Muslim 2704a, already agrees in source and grade and is left alone.
IN BUILD 153, FROM THE PHASE 2 READING: the counts above are corrected in place, the noun samʻ standing 22 times, the form at 2:181 being the verb, baʻdamā samiʻahu, and the ref now reads twenty-two. The carried line names Name 27 at 42:11 and 11:24, and the ḥadīth line Names 27 and 53 for Abū Mūsā’s report. The ref names Ibn Mājah 3861’s list beside at-Tirmidhī 3507’s. The 42:11 note gives Thaʻlab to the first parsing, the mithl the added element, as al-Qurṭubī has it, and the 2:127 note gives aṭ-Ṭabarī’s a group where it said most.
FROM THE CENSUS: Abū Mūsā’s report cites Muslim 2704a alone, whose wording it prints, al-Bukhārī 6384 standing in the note; at Names 27 and 53 the pair stands. The reflection’s ʻUmar on the road waits on the author (A34).
BY THE AUTHOR’S DECISIONS OF 2026-09-25, IN BUILD 182: MEDS 26 tells ʻUmar’s stopping in the road as a report whose chain Ibn Kathīr calls broken (A34).
IN BUILD 207, FROM THE READING OF THE GRADES: Muḥammad Fuʼād ʻAbd al-Bāqī is no longer named as a grader on this page: the row the ḥadīth dataset gives in his name is al-Albānī’s ruling as it is printed with ʻAbd al-Bāqī’s edition of Ibn Mājah, read at Shamela through its page reader, not in print, and the edition gives no verdict of its own beyond quoting az-Zawāʼid; al-Albānī’s grade stands where it stood, and earlier records keep their words.