ShowHide the Study Notes (976 words)
CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: SIX ayat. 39:4, with Ibn ʻĀshūr; 14:48, with ʻĀʼishah’s question as Ibn Kathīr cites it; 40:16, with Ibn Kathīr; 11:56, carried for the meaning and not as the root, with aṭ-Ṭabarī; 6:61, al-Qāhir, with aṭ-Ṭabarī and Ibn Kathīr — 11:56 and 6:61 at this Name only, and the other three shared with Name 66 since its pass; and, ADDED, 12:39, Yūsuf’s address to the two prisoners, SHARED WITH NAME 66, where it already stood, with aṭ-Ṭabarī and Ibn ʻĀshūr. It is appended; SHARED_LOCI now has reciprocal entries at 15 and 66, and the distinct Qurʼan-page verse count stays at 343, since 12:39 was already counted at Name 66.
NAMED HERE BUT NOT CARRIED ON THIS PAGE: 13:16 and 38:65, carried at Name 66; 6:18, carried at Name 46; 6:73, carried at Name 50 (named in build 148); 7:127 and 93:9, carried at NO Name; ADDED AT THE CHAT-END AUDIT OF 71–75, the entry names these verses, which this note did not list: 38:66, carried at Name 14;
CORRECTED ON THE RECORD, THE COUNTS: computed from the Tanzil text, al-Qahhār stands six times, each after al-Wāḥid, as the entry said; the root gives ten words in all, the six, al-Qāhir twice, qāhirūn once and taqhar once.
THE PAIRING: the desc and ref gave only single will can be irresistible as the reading of it, with no source; they now give Ibn ʻĀshūr on 12:39 and aṣ-Ṣanʻānī, whose words were read as quoted in a compilation at alsunna.net, as were al-Khaṭṭābī’s. Al-Ghazālī was read as quoted there and at islamic-content.com, and al-Qurṭubī’s al-Asnā only at the latter. Ibn Fāris was read on the islamweb transcription.
CORRECTED, THE DESC: its claims that what He subdues He returns to the order it was made for, and that He is the end of every unrighteous struggle, had no source and are removed.
THE ROOT: the gloss follows Ibn Fāris with glossBasis ref, and a senseNote is added.
CORRECTED, THE QURʼAN NOTES: 11:56 carried a process remark; 39:4, 14:48 and 40:16 carried unattributed readings; all now give the commentators. The 40:16 note had said the question is asked and answered with no one to contest it; the report that has Allah answer Himself is the long report of the Trumpet, which Ibn Kathīr calls very gharīb, and the note now says so. ONE duʻāʼ, SHARED WITH NAME 14.
CORRECTED ON THE RECORD, THE SOURCE: it gave an-Nasāʼī, as-Sunan al-Kubrā 10810, a number found in neither numbering read — 7641 and 10634 in the one cited at alsunna.net, 10700 in the one at dorar.net — so the source now names the Kubrā without a number, at both Names, and the note gives the numberings. The note had said al-Ḥākim graded it ṣaḥīḥ with adh-Dhahabī concurring; that ruling was not read, and the claim is removed; the grade stands on al-Albānī, Ṣaḥīḥ al-Jāmiʻ 4693, and as-Silsilah aṣ-Ṣaḥīḥah 2066. Its capitals and process remarks are removed. TWO tracked aḥādīth. al-Bukhārī 6527 with Muslim 2859a, from ʻĀʼishah, SHARED WITH NAME 87 as another portion (corrected in build 148): CORRECTED, its grade pointed to a wording variance above that stands below in the note; the grade now reads ṣaḥīḥ (muttafaq ʻalayh), and the note states that the root is absent and gives ʻĀʼishah’s question.
ADDED: Muslim 2791, ʻĀʼishah’s question on 14:48, carried at this Name only.
POEMS 15: the eye of a hurricane is no longer called complete calm, and Al-Qahhār no longer never has to raise His voice, which speaks of how He speaks; it now says He has never had to prove Himself.
MEDS 15: the pairing is given as the commentators read it; the old verse and old story are named as Hūd’s and Yūsuf’s; it no longer says the self cannot be mastered, which sets aside the striving the Sunnah commands, but that it is not mastered alone, citing the strong man who owns himself in anger; the prayer is quoted in the book’s translation of Abū Dāwūd 5090; and Sovereign, Al-Malik’s word, is now the Subduer. CH 15 checked and unchanged; at 419 words it is above the story median of 351, left to the author.
AUDIT: this line first gave the length as about 540 words, a miscount, corrected by script.
AUDIT, FINAL CHECK OF NAMES 1 TO 25: MEDS 15’s tradition teaching you to ask for help becomes the Prophet ﷺ teaching the asking, quoting Abū Dāwūd 5090 in Name 1’s translation.
AFTER NAME 84: 40:16 is carried at Name 84 too, with the same Arabic and English, linked exactly.
IN BUILD 148, FROM THE PHASE 2 READING: the report line above is corrected in place. Muslim 2859a stands at Name 87 as well, the longer portion with ʻĀʼishah’s question and his answer, added in Name 87’s pass after that line was written; the two are now linked as other portions, and source and grade read Muslim 2859a and ṣaḥīḥ (muttafaq ʻalayh) at both. The two Englishes of the shared clause still differ by a serial comma, which waits on the author (A23). The ref gives al-Khaṭṭābī, al-Ghazālī, aṣ-Ṣanʻānī and al-Qurṭubī’s al-Asnā as quoted in later works, and the duʻāʼ note aṣ-Ṣanʻānī, as this note records they were read. The ref places Ibn Kathīr’s verdict on the report of the Trumpet where he gives the report whole, at 6:73, very gharīb, Ismāʻīl ibn Rāfiʻ alone transmitting it, where it had set the verdict at 40:16, which has none; 6:73 is named in the line above. The 11:56 note calls ākhidhun a participle, not a verb.
FROM THE CENSUS: the report’s source field cites Muslim 2859a alone, the record that carries the printed Arabic, al-Bukhārī 6527 standing in the note.
IN BUILD 185, FROM THE PHASE 2 READING OF NAME 66: 12:39 is linked to Name 66 as the same text, as 14:48, 39:4 and 40:16 are.